WPCr [a%},>(x%L8X1˯`i0l%@fxĶ'r:8$~텬/XE-gk3& gk1Eģc\&Iw—v+![++Ɣ+8X0"ax'Ub6=3B\#UN % 0(% UBM ^ w 4   m 1u NP 72R U> e U>  0l  0D A 0D D+ 0K        BUHP LaserJet 5Si,,,,0(9 Z6Times New Roman Regular($< 9(*Courier 10cpiBold5 va~53|xU3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a) i)\  `&Times New Romanx9 Z&Times New Roman { $    1    _ ` Thegovernmentsinstructionuses machineguninthetitleof  instructionsonbothcounts,doubtlessanoversight.Thiswouldhavetobethe  instructionforCount2involvingashortbarreled_shotgun._((3$ !      0  Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5(#$  0  PTS I&mage <=8C HKKKK(3$ !  'dxd( $ Figure  1   d !  _ (#33 8XXdd8 @e e INTHEUNITEDSTATESDISTRICTCOURT  @ WESTERNDISTRICTOFARKANSAS  @ FAYETTEVILLEDIVISION (  UNITEDSTATESOFAMERICAB(#PLAINTIFF N vs.@q q CRIMINALCASENO.5:06cr50064_JLH_Ԅ1##Ԉ " r HOLLISWAYNE_FINCHER_B(#DEFENDANT##ӈ F  @  DEFENDANTSJURYINSTRUCTIONS      ComesnowHollisWayne_Fincher_Ԁandproposesthefollowingjury  instructions. * Respectfullysubmitted, N    `     h   By:򀀀/s/OscarStilley "r    `     h   OscarStilley,AttorneyatLaw 4    `     h   701S.21stStreet F    `     h   FortSmith,AR72901 X    `     h   (479)5730726 j    `     h   AttorneyforDefendant |  @ CERTIFICATEOFSERVICE 󀀀   !   I,OscarStilley,bymysignatureabovecertifythatIhavethis"US ,   December27, # 2006!  Ԁservedthefollowingby_ECF_: $,   WendyL.Johnson## Ԁ 'P"  U.S.Attorney'sOffice (h#! P.O.Box1524 *)z$" 414ParkerAvenue# # <*%# FortSmith,AR72902# #  N+&$ @ STATEMENTWITHRESPECTTOAGREEDINSTRUCTIONS     Defensecounselhasconferredwithgovernmentcounselandconcludedthat & themostefficientmethodofproceedingistoagreeonthatwhichisagreed,and J thustoonlytroubletheCourtwithextrapaperwhereadisputeexists.  n   TheDefendant,reservinghisrighttofurtherobjectortoproposemore B  properinstructionsormodificationstotheinstructionsofeitherparty,havingbeen f  providedwithacopyofthegovernmentsinstructions,setsforthalistof   instructionsproposedbythegovernment,andfurtherindicatesiftheinstructionis  deemedagreed,partlyagreed,orobjectedto.Defendantherewithsubmits " substantiveinstructionsforbothcountsoftheindictmentandforentrapment. F    >  8thCir.No.1.01  GENERALNATUREOFCASE;NATUREOFINDICTMENT;BURDEN ( OFPROOF;PRESUMPTIONOFINNOCENCE;DUTYOFJURY;   P   Thisinstructionisagreedinprinciple.Theword chargeshouldbe ( x pluralized,__Ԁbutthetreatmentofthesecondcountshouldbeconsistentwiththe L  treatmentofthefirstcount. p   8thCir.1.02ELEMENTSOFTHEOFFENSE(PRELIMINARY)      Notagreed.Defendantdoesnotagreethattheelementsofeachoffenseare   correctlystated.Defendantsubmitsthatthisinstructionisunnecessary. 0  1.03EVIDENCE;LIMITATIONS T  0  Agreed.,|(#(#  [nonumber]Directv.circumstantialevidence  P   Agreed. x  1.05CREDIBILITYOFTHEWITNESS      Agreed. "  1.08CONDUCTOFTHEJURY  $8    Agreed. '`"   1.09PRELIMINARYINSTRUCTIONSBEFOREOPENING 4)$" STATEMENTS OUTLINEOFTRIAL  \+&$   Agreed.   3.01INTRODUCTION  $   Agreedexceptthatthelastsentenceshouldbestricken. L  3.02;D&B18.10MODIFIEDDUTYOFJURY   p   Agreedexceptastothelastsentenceofthefirstparagraph.Defendant H  contendsthatthissentenceshouldbestricken,inwhichcasetheinstructionis l  agreeabletotheDefendant.    3.03EVIDENCE;LIMITATIONS     Agreed. ,  3.04CREDIBILITYOFWITNESSES  P   Agreed. (x  3.06DESCRIPTIONOFCHARGES;INDICTMENTNOTEVIDENCE; L PRESUMPTIONOFINNOCENCE;BURDENOFPROOF(SINGLE t DEFENDANT,MULTIPLECOUNTS)      Agreed. "  3.11REASONABLEDOUBT  $8    Agreed. '`"   4.10OPINIONEVIDENCE,EXPERTWITNESS  4)$"   Agreed. \+&$  6.26.5861ELEMENTSOFOFFENSEFIREARMS!POSSESSIONOF  MACHINEGUN(18U.S.C.)922(o)  (   Notagreed,Defendantsubmitsadifferentinstruction.  P  6.26.5861ELEMENTSOFOFFENSEFIREARMS!POSSESSIONOFAN $ t UNREGISTEREDFIREARM #  1      ׀(18U.S.C.)922(o)  L    Notagreed,Defendantsubmitsadifferentinstruction. t   D&B13.05INDICTMENT, ONORABOUT      Agreed.   7.03 KNOWINGLYDEFINED  4   Agreedifthesecondsentenceoftheinstructionisstricken.Otherwise  \ disagreed. 0  7.05PROOFOFINTENTORKNOWLEDGE  T   Agreed. |  [nonumber] FIREARMDEFINITION      Disagreed. "  8.02POSSESSION:ACTUAL,CONSTRUCTIVE,SOLE,JOINT  $<    Agreed. 'd"   3.12ELECTIONOFFOREPERSON;DUTYTODELIBERATE;  PUNISHMENTNOTAFACTOR;COMMUNICATIONSWITHCOURT; ( CAUTIONARY;VERDICTFORM   P   Agreed. ( x  2.05WIRETAPOROTHERTAPERECORDEDEVIDENCE  L    Agreedifthelanguage Theseconversationswerelegallyrecorded,andis t  stricken.    2.06TRANSCRIPTOFTAPERECORDEDCONVERSATION      Agreed. 4  4.05aCREDIBILITYCOOPERATINGWITNESS  X   Agreed. 0  4.06TESTIMONYOFINFORMER  T   Agreed. |  2.08DEFENDANTSPRIORSIMILARACTS      Disagreed.Defendantwillobjecttothepresentationofevidenceofactsnot " chargedintheindictment.Defendantcontendsthatthisinstructionwillbe $<  altogetherunnecessary. '`"   ADDITIONALINSTRUCTIONS  4)$" Entrapment. \+&$    @ DEFENDANTSPROPOSEDINSTRUCTIONNO.򀀀    18_USC_Ԁ922(o)POSSESSIONOFPROHIBITEDMACHINEGUNS  (   Thecrimeofpossessionofaprohibitedmachinegun,aschargedinCount1  P oftheIndictment,hasfourelements,whichare:   0  0` (#(#One,thedefendantknewthathehadinhispossessionamachinegun 6  capableofoperatingasdesigned,whichdesignpermittedthegunto  !  dischargemorethanasingleround(bullet)withasinglepullofthe l  trigger,andthatsuchpossessionwasnotbyorundertheauthorityof, W  theUnitedStatesoranydepartmentoragencythereoforaState,ora   department,agency,orpoliticalsubdivisionthereof;and=` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#Two,themachineguncouldnotreasonablycontributetothecommon ( defenseoftheUnitedStatesortheStateofArkansas,asamilitary s arm,asamilitaryarmprotectedbythe2ndAmendmentoftheUS ^ ConstitutionandArticle25oftheArkansasConstitution,and  whoseonlyreasonableandprobableusewasthereforeforcriminal D purposes;/` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#Three,themachinegunwasnotregisteredtothedefendantinthe z  NationalFirearmsRegistrationandTransferRecord,norpossessed !e" bytheaccusedpriortoJanuary1,1987;and"$` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#Four,themachinegun,intheconditionspecificallydescribedinthis K$& juryinstruction,wastraffickedininterstatecommerce. Interstate %6!( commerceforpurposesofthisinstructionincludesanysale,barter, '"* orothertransactionforcommercialprofitbetweenasellerinone )l$, Stateandabuyerin;*&.` (#` (#    `  A)AnyplaceoutsideofthatState,or  0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#B)AnyplacewithinanypossessionoftheUnitedStates(not K includingtheCanalZone)ortheDistrictofColumbia, 6 EXCEPT  (# (# 0  0` (#(#Suchtermdoesnotincludecommercebetweenplaceswithinthe  l sameStatebutthroughanyplaceoutsideofthatState.Theterm    "State"includestheDistrictofColumbia,theCommonwealthof R  PuertoRico,andthepossessionsoftheUnitedStates(notincluding =  theCanalZone). ` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#Five,themachinegunwasnotpossessedbyorundertheauthorityof, #s theUnitedStatesoranydepartmentoragencythereoforaState,ora  department,agency,orpoliticalsubdivisionthereof;Y` (#` (#  18_USC_Ԁ922(o)(no8thCircuitpatterninstruction)  V @ DEFENDANTSPROPOSEDINSTRUCTIONNO.򀀀    8thCir.6.26.5861FIREARMSPOSSESSIONOFUNREGISTERED & SHORTBARRELEDSHOTGUN(26U.S.C.5861(d))  :   Thecrimeofpossessionofanunregisteredshortbarreledshotgun,as  ` chargedinCount2oftheIndictment,hasfourelements,whichare: 4  0  0` (#(#One,thedefendantknewhehadinhispossessionashotgunhavinga X  barrelorbarrelslessthan18inchesinlength,andthatsuch |  possessionwasnotbyorundertheauthorityof,theUnitedStatesor   anydepartmentoragencythereoforaState,oradepartment,agency,  orpoliticalsubdivisionthereof;8` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#Two,thedesignandoperationoftheshotgunwassuchthatitcould  \ notreasonablycontributetothecommondefenseoftheUnitedStates 0 ortheStateofArkansas,asamilitaryarmprotectedbythe2nd T AmendmentoftheUSConstitutionandArticle25oftheArkansas x Constitution,andwhoseonlyreasonableandprobableusewas ! thereforeforcriminalpurposes;#` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#Three,theshortbarreledshotgunwasnotregisteredtothedefendant %4! intheNationalFirearmsRegistrationandTransferRecord;(X#!` (#` (# 0  0` (#(#Four,theshortbarreledshotgun,inthespecificconditiondescribed ,*|%# inthisjuryinstruction,wastraffickedininterstatecommerce.   Interstatecommerceforpurposesofthisinstructionincludesany $ sale,barter,orothertransactionforcommercialprofitbetweenany H placeinoneStateand; l` (#` (#    `  A)AnyplaceoutsideofthatState,or @  0  0` (#(#0 ` (#` (#B)AnyplacewithinanypossessionoftheUnitedStates(not d  includingtheCanalZone)ortheDistrictofColumbia,   EXCEPT (# (# 0  0` (#(#Suchtermdoesnotincludecommercebetweenplaceswithinthe   sameStatebutthroughanyplaceoutsideofthatState.Theterm D "State"includestheDistrictofColumbia,theCommonwealthof h PuertoRico,andthepossessionsoftheUnitedStates(notincluding < theCanalZone).`` (#` (#  8thCir.6.26.5861(modified)  " @ DEFENDANTSPROPOSEDINSTRUCTIONNO.򀀀    8thCir.9.01 ENTRAPMENT  (   Oneoftheissuesinthiscaseiswhetherthedefendantwasentrapped, , | becauseheinformedvariousgovernmentofficialsandagenciesofthetypesof P  gunsinhispossessionandexpressedhisbeliefthathehadalegalrighttopossess t  suchguns.Itisuncontestedthatthesegovernmentofficialsneverrespondedto   saythattheprivateownershipofsuchgunscontravenedanyvalidlawofthe   UnitedStates.Ifthedefendantwasentrapped,hemustbefoundnotguilty.The 0 Governmenthastheburdenofprovingbeyondareasonabledoubtthatthe T defendantwasnotentrapped. (x   IfthedefendantbeforecontactwiththegovernoroftheStateofArkansas, L theBureauofAlcohol,Tobacco,andFirearms(_BATF_)didnothaveanyintentor p dispositiontocommitthecrimechargedandwasinducedorpersuadedbythe   words,actions,orinactionoftheseagencies,ortheirofficer(s)oragent(s)to " willfullycommitthatcrime,knowingsametobecontrarytoavalidand $,  constitutionallawoftheUnitedStates,thenhewasentrapped.Ontheotherhand, 'P"  ifthedefendantbeforecontactwiththeabovedescribedentitiesandpartiesdid $)t$" haveanintentordispositiontowillfullyandintentionallycommitthecrime H+&$ charged,thenhewasnotentrapped,eventhoughtheabovedescribedentitiesor  partiesprovidedafavorableopportunitytocommitthecrimeormadecommitting $ thecrimeeasierorevenparticipatedinactsessentialtothecrime. H  8thCir.9.01(modified)  @  _ @e e INTHEUNITEDSTATESDISTRICTCOURT  @ WESTERNDISTRICTOFARKANSAS ( @ FAYETTEVILLEDIVISION  P  UNITEDSTATESOFAMERICAB(#PLAINTIFF L  vs.@q q CRIMINALCASENO.5:06cr50064JLH1#C#Ԉ   HOLLISWAYNEFINCHERB(#DEFENDANT# D#Ԉ , @QQ$ VERDICTFORM  H   We,thejury,onthechargesintheindictmentofHollisWayneFincher,for   ourverdictsay:#D# " 2 #  1  .3    Wefindtheaccused,HollisWayneFincher,astoCount1. $,  Ѐ(NotGuilty)or(Guilty)[circleone] 'P"  #E#2 #  2  .3    Wefindtheaccused,HollisWayneFincher,astoCount2. $)t$" Ѐ(NotGuilty)or(Guilty)[circleone]#F# H+&$ #G#[completethefollowingonlyintheeventofaguiltyverdictononeorbothcounts] $ 2 #  3  .3    Wefindthatthenumberofgunspossessedknowinglyinviolationofthe H lawsoftheUnitedStates,chargedbythegrandjuryintheirindictment,is  l ____________(herefixthenumberofsuchgunsunanimouslyfoundand @  determinedtobythejurytohavebeenpossessedbytheaccused)#EH#